Appeals Court Gives Insurers a CSR Win, but Limits Payout
Health insurers that sued to recoup halted cost-sharing reduction (CSR) payments scored a key victory on Aug. 14 when a federal appeals court confirmed that the government must reimburse them for providing subsidies to low-income Affordable Care Act exchange enrollees. But that win came with a significant catch, as the three-judge panel said insurers can collect only the monetary damages that they didn’t already recoup from silver loading — the process by which they raise benchmark silver-plan premiums to compensate for lost CSR payments.
Health policy experts who spoke to AIS Health say they don’t expect the court’s decisions will cause much to change about CSRs or silver loading, as the current setup is working well for nearly all stakeholders. Still, insurers probably won’t file any more lawsuits seeking CSR reimbursement from the 2018 plan years and beyond, since they aren’t likely to collect any damages.